West Ham flop is fast becoming their worst signing since Scamacca
It would be fair to say that West Ham United have not had the best of luck when it comes to transfers over the last decade or so.
Sure, the Hammers have signed seriously talented players like Jarrod Bowen and Lucas Paqueta, but they’ve also made more than their fair share of dud signings.
Hopefully, with Nuno Espírito Santo in the hotseat ahead of the winter window, the club will start making some smart acquisitions.
However, in addition to bringing in talent, West Ham should also be looking to offload some players, including one who might just be their worst signing since Gianluca Scamacca.
West Ham's flop signings
You only have to go back to last summer for some examples of West Ham’s poor decision-making in the market, with Max Kilman and Niclas Füllkrug now looking like terrible additions to the squad.
The former cost around £40m, and while he’s had a few games in which he’s impressed, he’s had far more in which he’s been a liability, and to make things worse, former manager Gary O’Neil described him as a defender who tends to “switch off” during games.
The German striker, on the other hand, only cost around £27m, but has arguably been an even worse investment for the East Londoners.
On top of missing plenty of games through injury, he’s just not been very good when he has played and is now set to join AC Milan, having chalked up a measly tally of three goals and two assists in 29 games.
In fact, the former Borussia Dortmund star has been such a disappointment at the London Stadium that he has made Scamacca’s time in the capital look better.
With that said, the Italian striker, who joined the Irons from Sassuolo in the summer of 2022 for a fee of around £30.5m, was still a disappointment, though.
The 26-year-old made the move off the back of an impressive season in which he had scored 16 goals and provided one assist for a mid-table side, so there was an expectation that he could be the one to spearhead David Moyes’ side.
Unfortunately, it just wasn’t to be, as the 6 foot 5 poacher struggled to impose himself on opposition teams and ended the campaign with just eight goals in 27 games.
Worse yet, just three of those goals came in the league, and even then, they came against Fulham, Leeds United and Wolverhampton.
Scamacca’s West Ham record
Competition
Games
G+As
EPL
16
3
FA Cup
1
0
EFL Cup
1
0
UECL
7
3
UECL Qualification
2
2
All Stats via Transfermarkt
The Rome-born striker would leave the following summer, and while he was undoubtedly a flop, there is someone in Nuno’s current team who might’ve been an even worse signing.
The West Ham signing worse than Scamacca
Unfortunately, for Nuno and Co, you could probably make the case for several current West Ham players fitting this description, from the pair mentioned above to Mads Hermansen and James Ward-Prowse.
Chalkboard
Football FanCast’s Chalkboard series presents a tactical discussion from around the global game.
However, in this instance, the unenviable title goes to Konstantinos Mavropanos.
Now, to be clear, like most transfer flops, the Greek international has shown moments of quality here and there, but overall, since his £19m move to the club two years ago, he’s been poor.
On the one hand, he’s not got the technical ability to be a modern ball-playing centre-back, and yet he also struggles to make the most of his frame to bully opposition attackers.
Subscribe for smarter transfer analysis and scouting Want deeper context on signings like Mavropanos and other transfer flops? Subscribe to our newsletter for data-driven scouting reports, smart transfer analysis and clearer takes on club strategy and squad building — plus wider football insight. Subscribe for smarter transfer analysis and scouting Want deeper context on signings like Mavropanos and other transfer flops? Subscribe to our newsletter for data-driven scouting reports, smart transfer analysis and clearer takes on club strategy and squad building — plus wider football insight.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
Unsurprisingly, his underlying numbers help to demonstrate how lacklustre he’s been.
Mavropanos’ Scout Report
Statistics
Per 90
Percentile
Pass Completion %
86.9%
Bottom 43%
Progressive Carries
0.42
Bottom 32%
Assists
0.00
Bottom 28%
Tackles
1.08
Bottom 19%
Progressive Passes
2.21
Bottom 17%
Dribblers Tackled
0.42
Bottom 7%
All Stats via FBref
According to FBref, he ranks in the bottom 47% of centre-backs in Europe’s top five leagues for blocks, the bottom 43% for pass completion, the bottom 19% for tackles, the bottom 7% for dribblers tackled and more, all per 90.
With that said, you don’t need the numbers to know that, in the words of The Athletic’s Roshane Thomas, he often has “no clue” where to go or what to do in intense moments.
An example of this lack of awareness was on full display in the draw against Everton earlier this season.
Ultimately, Mavropanos is not a terrible player, but he’s not been good enough, and he likely never will be for West Ham.
West Ham submit bid to sign Wilson upgrade who "doesn't stop scoring"
The incredible goalscorer would be an unreal signing for West Ham, but bad news for Wilson.
ByJack Salveson Holmes